- A federal judge in Manhattan granted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno a judgment of acquittal on wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, CoinDesk reported. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke ruled on Nov. 16 and directed the clerk to close the case, the government’s first criminal prosecution over the practice known as MEV.
- Prosecutors accused the brothers of making $25 million in 12 seconds in April 2023 by luring sandwich trading bots with eight bait transactions. The brothers’ validator signed a block header with two fields set to zero, and a relay called Ultrasound released the bots’ trades without checking.
- The ruling comes a year after a jury deadlocked and Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025. The bots lost about $25 million, while the brothers’ validator was penalized about 1 ether, worth a few thousand dollars.
- Clarke wrote that Ethereum is “a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” and that no trader placing a transaction in the public mempool “would agree to be sandwiched.” She said the case turned on whether the conduct was wire fraud, not whether it was right or moral.
What Happened?
Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation, a lie that matters to whoever is deceived. Judge Clarke found the bait trades made no promise, and that the false signature on the block header had “no effect on the behavior of its recipient” because the relay never checked those fields. She cited a 2022 Second Circuit ruling that conduct that is “improper, objectionable, or even despicable” is not enough, while acknowledging the brothers hid their plans and may have frustrated the relay software’s design.
Why It Matters?
The decision sets a notable boundary for how US criminal law treats on-chain trading strategies. With no criminal case behind them, the sandwich-bot operators who were themselves running such trades were left without recourse, and the ruling suggests that exploiting protocol rules, absent a deception that was relied on, may fall outside wire-fraud statutes. Only one wallet holding about $3 million of the proceeds was ever frozen, and the brothers moved the rest out by October 2023.
What’s Next?
The key questions are whether prosecutors appeal and whether regulators or Congress pursue rules aimed at MEV extraction and relay design instead of relying on fraud statutes. Builders of relays and validators will likely review verification practices, since the case turned on a relay not checking the falsified fields. Traders running MEV strategies will watch for any change in enforcement posture.
Affected Tickers and Coins: ETH, COIN
Source: CoinDesk













