Key Takeaways
Powered by lumidawealth.com
- A growing share of unsold for-sale homes is shifting to rentals (≈2.3% of listed homes this summer; >5% in some Sunbelt cities), adding supply and weighing on rent growth.
- John Burns projects 2025 SFR rent growth of about 0.8% in the top 20 markets—the slowest since 2011—despite high occupancy and healthy rent-to-income metrics.
- Sunbelt concentration risk is elevated for large SFR REITs; new-lease rents are falling in several TX/FL markets even as in-place rents rise, widening the gap and raising future churn risk.
What Happened?
Soft absorption in the for-sale market is spilling into rentals. Of 3.06 million homes listed at the start of summer, only 28% sold; roughly 1.96 million rolled into fall listings (+20% y/y), and 2.3% of listed homes converted to rentals. Sunbelt markets (Atlanta, Dallas, Phoenix, Houston, Tampa, Charlotte) see the highest conversion and inventory, where major SFR landlords are concentrated. Invitation Homes reported negative new-lease rent growth in parts of TX/FL (e.g., Tampa, Orlando, Jacksonville, Dallas) even as it increased renewals (e.g., +6.2% for in-place tenants in South Florida). Inventory in Dallas and Tampa is up 25% and 39% versus Aug 2019, respectively, with rental listings also elevated.
Why it matters
Rental supply “leakage” from the for-sale market compresses pricing power for large SFR portfolios, particularly in oversupplied Sunbelt corridors. Landlords are offsetting weaker new-lease rates by raising renewals, but widening spreads between in-place and market rents can incentivize tenant turnover, pressuring occupancy and NOI ahead. Public SFR names are underperforming the S&P 500 and also lagging multi-family REITs and homebuilders, reflecting rising risk to near-term same-home rent growth. Paradoxically, lower mortgage rates would help clear for-sale inventory (reducing rental leakage) but could also lift rental vacancies as tenants regain buying power. With transaction volumes at multi-decade lows and “shadow inventory” building via delistings-turned-rentals, the operating environment remains challenging despite a record renter base.
What’s next
Focus on market-level rent prints (new vs. renewal spreads), turnover and occupancy in Sunbelt-heavy portfolios; monitor listing inventory and rental postings in Dallas, Tampa, Orlando, Jacksonville, Phoenix and Houston. Watch management guidance on 2025 same-home NOI, renewal cadence, concessions, and capex for turn costs. Track mortgage-rate moves and for-sale absorption as key swing factors for rental supply. Portfolio diversification toward Midwest/West Coast markets showing healthier rent growth may mitigate concentration risk.
